PAKISTAN ADMININSTRATIVE SERVICE
ALUMNI RESEARCH CENTER
Peer Review Form
AREA OF THE PAPER / MANUSCRIPT/WORK
PAPER / MANUSCRIPT PROFILE
PLEASE RATE THE FOLLOWING BY CHECKING AN ‘X’ IN THE BOXES THAT IN YOUR OPINION, BEST DESCRIBE THE FOLLOWING FEATURES OF THE PAPER / MANUSCRIPT/ WORK:
(5 = EXCELLENT, 1 = POOR)
5
4
3
2
1
N/A
RELEVANCE TO THE THEMES OF PADAP
CONTRIBUTION TO ACADEMIC DEBATE
STRUCTURE OF THE PAPER / MANUSCRIPT/ WORK
STANDARD OF ENGLISH
APPROPIATENESS OF THE RESEARCH/STUDY METHOD
RELEVANCE AND CLARITY OF TEXT, DRAWINGS, GRAPHS AND TABLES
APPROPIATENESS OF ABSTRACT AS A DESCRIPTION OF THE PAPER/ MANUSCRIPT/WORK
APPROPIATENESS AND NUMBER OF KEYWORDS/KEY PHRASES
ORIGINALITY OF THE WORK
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE OTHERS WORK BY PROPER REFERENCES
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
RELEVANCE OF THE RESEARCH RESULTS TO POLICY DEVELOPMENT IN THE PAPER/MANUSCRIPT/WORK AREA
REFERENCE LIST, ADEQUATE AND CORRECTLY CITED
REVIEWER COMMENTS
TO ASSIST THE AUTHOR/S IN REVISING THIS PAPER/MANUSCRIPT/WORK, PLEASE REPORT IN THE FOLLOWINGS THE SPECIFIC REVIEWER COMMENTS TO BE PASSED TO THE AUTHOR/S. PLEASE EXPAND ON ANY WEAK AREAS IN THE CHECKLIST AND OFFER SPECIFIC ADVISE AS TO HOW THE AUTHOR/S MAY IMPROVE THE PAPER/MANUSCRIPT/WORK.
REVIEWER RECOMMENDATION
CAN THIS PAPER/MANUSCRIPT/WORK BE ACCEPTED FOR BEING PUBLISHED IN THE PADAP?
(CHECK ONLY ONE PLACE, PLEASE)
REVIEWER CONTACT DATA

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form